If you are shopping for acoustic guitar, chances are you would be looking at a Martin D-18 or an HD-28. The reason is that they are probably the more popular and well-loved acoustic guitars out there.
If you are not sure which of these two guitars to pick, you are in the right place. In this post, I will compare between the D-18 and HD-28 and help you decide which suits you better. We present to you the Battle of the Martins: D-18 vs. HD-28.
The D-18 is less expensive and lighter than the HD-28. Both guitars use different wood backing, producing different sound profiles. The D-18 is warmer in sound, focusing more on the middle range. The HD-28 is more bright and crisper, with more boom and bass.
What Is Martin D-18?
Introduced in 1931, the Martin D-18 is a gold standard in acoustic guitar, well-loved by musicians and sound engineers, amateur and professional alike. It has a rich sound, strong mid-range, with a tight low-end sound. It also has a timeless and understated design, perfect for those that like simple, classical-looking guitars.
The D18 is probably one of the most popular acoustic guitars from Martin. Introduced in 1931, it has remained a popular choice amongst many guitarists, amateur and professional. Its classic and timeless look also appeals to many.
The D18 features a solid spruce top, while the back and sides are solid mahogany wood. Martin probably spent a lot of time fine-tuning this wood combination, resulting in a classic Martin sound that guitarists worldwide love and admire. Martin D18 has been played by many great artists, including Elvis Presley, Kurt Cobain, Do Watson, Paul Simon, and many more.
The D18’s neck is made of wood, while the fretboard is smooth ebony. These materials are said to be ‘wrist-friendly,’ as they are not too hard and comfortable. This makes the D18 easier to play with and important to those that will play long hours on stage.
EQ analysis revealed that the Martin D18 has a strong mid-range and tight low-end sound. This makes the D18 excellent for recording, as the sound engineer will have a wider range of sound when mixing.
The thing about D18 is that even if you know little about guitars, you will like how it looks and may guess it is worth a lot of money. It has that timeless, classical look that is simple, understated, but full of quality.
What Is Martin HD-28?
The Martin HD-28 is a dreadnought-shaped acoustic guitar with a solid spruce top, Rosewood back, and sides. It is a minor upgrade from the Martin D-28 guitar. The HD-28 has a crisp, bright, authoritative sound with strong bass and boom. Artists that play with HD-28 include Bob Dylan, James Hetfield, etc.
The HD-28 goes back even earlier than the D-18. The HD-28 can be traced back to its earliest form in 1917, as Martin’s first dreadnought guitar. It then became D-28 in 1931, before minor changes introduced the HD-28 in 1975.
The major difference between the D-28 and the HD-28 is the backing, which gives HD-28 a slightly different sound profile. Some may consider it a marginal improvement, while many still prefer the sounds of the original D-28.
The HD-28 is made with a solid spruce top and Rosewood back and sides. This allows the HD-28 to produce a crisp, clear, and authoritative sound that will turn heads and stop any conversation when you run a strum on it. The HD-28 is also very well appreciated for its strong bass sound, with a strong low end, resulting in more boom.
Because the HD28 has a modern neck profile, it is very easy to play. It also features small details that give it a vintage feel, such as open-gear tuners, antique white accents, and a faux tortoise pickguard.
If you are still not convinced by the HD28, just look at the artists who recorded and performed with HD-28: James Hetfield, Chris Martin, Bob Dylan, Ben Howard, etc.
How Similar are Martin D-18 and HD-28?
Martin D-18 and HD-28 share many similar physical appearances, such as body shape and size, neck length, satin neck finishing, body finishing, string gauge, etc. It also shares similar characteristics in playability and reliability.
Body: Both D-18 and HD-28 are in dreadnought shape and have remained so since they were introduced to the market decades ago. The size is also similar to the D-14 Fret size. D-14 is Martin’s particular way of sizing their guitars, with the D meaning ‘Dreadnought,’ while the 14 refers to 14-fret size. Both guitar bodies have a gloss finish to retain that classic, timeless, vintage-ish look.
Scale Length: Scale length points to how long the length between the nut and saddle of a string is. It measures the whole string that is freely vibrating when you pluck it. D-18 and HD-28 have a scale length of 25.4 inches (64.5cm.)
Neck: D-18 and HD-28 share many similarities with the neck construction. Both use mahogany wood for their neck, with a modified low oval shape. Both necks are also given a satin finish. The fingerboard consists of 20 frets, not to be confused with the guitar’s sizes of D-14 Fret.
Top: Both guitars use solid Sitka Spruce wood for the top part of their shell, with gloss finishing. Both tops have a tortoise-type pickguard with an ebony bridge. The saddle is made of compensated bone, with a radius of 16 inches (40.6cm). Both guitar tops also feature multi-striped rosettes.
Bracing: Bracing refers to the braces or additional wood strips installed under the top of a guitar. Bracing manipulates the movement of vibrations inside the box. It helps to create tonal quality that makes guitars sound different from each other. Guitar makers like manipulating the bracing structures to produce their own signature sound.
D-18 and HD-28 have similar bracing structures in that X-bracing for both the guitar models has scalloped bracing. The X-bracing refers to an X-shaped strip of wood, usually attached to the underside of the guitar’s top side. It is commonly placed right under the sound hole.
Scalloped bracing is created by removing some of the wood in the center of the straight wood brace, creating a wide U-shape. Scalloped bracing is known to help accentuate the mid ranges of the sound profile. This results in a more balanced and rich sound.
Reliability & Playability
Reliability: D-18 and HD-28 are reliable and incredibly sturdy guitars. You can expect them to play well and last for a long time. The wood is solid, with the joined neck almost invisible, except to the sharpest of eyes.
With good care and proper maintenance, the guitar should stay playable and perform at its best years into the future. There have been cases where Martin D-18 or HD-28 guitars were handed down as heirlooms.
Martin also backs their guitar with a lifetime limited warranty on manufacturing defects, which means you can purchase your guitar with peace of mind.
Playability: Many players who have played the D-18 and the HD-28 have mentioned that both guitars have a finger-friendly feel. The bridge is not too high, meaning the strings are easier to press on the fretboard. Many players noted the less hard fretboard as well.
Many players also noted that the fretboard’s shape made it easier on their wrists. They did not have to manipulate their wrists too much to ensure they got all the strings pressed down properly.
These special features may mean D-18 and HD-28 are excellent performance guitars since you can play on them for hours without feeling too tired on your wrist and fingers. Perhaps this is one of the reasons why performers such as Bob Dylan, Johnny Cash, or Neil Young use them.
Martin D-18 vs. HD-28: How Do They Differ?
Martin D-18 and HD-28 differ in physical appearance, sound quality, playability, pricing, and weight. These differences eventually resulted in a guitarist preferring either one of the guitars.
D-18 and HD-28 have some physical differences. Most are cosmetic, although certain differences, such as bracing and wood type, result in different sound quality.
|D-18||Features & Characteristics||HD-28|
|Solid Mahogany||Back & Side||Solid East Indian Rosewood|
|Square Taper||Headstock Shape||Square Taper and Diamond|
|Abalone, in dots||Inlays||Abalone, in diamonds- and-squares pattern|
|Ply Hardshell||Case||Molded Hardshell|
Back & Side: While the D-18 and HD-28 use spruce for their top body, they use different wood for the back and side of the guitar. The D-18 uses solid mahogany, while the HD-28 uses solid East Indian Rosewood.
Solid means the wood pieces are in a single piece, instead of several pieces joined into one. This gives the guitar greeted sound and tone quality. Mahogany is generally less dense than Rosewood, meaning the vibration escapes from the wood more easily. This gives it a brighter sound compared to Rosewood.
Headstock Shape: The D-18 keeps a square taper headstock shape, while the HD-28 uses a square taper and diamond shape. Headstock shapes generally do not influence sound quality. However, the square taper and diamond shape have a more vintage and classical look than the square taper, which may appeal to players.
Inlays: Inlays are also known as fretboard markers. They are usually embedded into the guitar necks and help you to visually tell which fret your finger is on. Common guitars tend to use simple dots. However, more expensive guitars tend to insert more premium materials in different shapes than dots.
In the case of the D-18, it places abalone shells into the fret in a simple rounded dot shape. The HD-28 also uses abalone shells, but instead of a rounded dot, you get a diamond-and-square shape. These differences are only cosmetic in nature and should not affect sound quality or playability.
Case: The guitar case is where you keep your guitar. It keeps your guitar protected from knocks or dust exposure. It also makes it easier to travel with. The D-18 comes with a ply hardshell case, while the HD-28 comes with a more premium molded hardshell case.
D-18 has a warmer and fuller sound, with a strong focus on the middle range. The HD-28 has a richer, brighter sound, with more boom. The differences lie in the choice of wood and the bracing used.
D-18: The D-18 is given a solid Mahogany wood for its back and side. Mahogany is a less dense wood, which means when there is vibration inside the guitar body, more air can escape from it. This will likely cause the D-18 to have less ‘boom’ in its sound. When the sound has less difficulty getting out from the guitar box, it helps it to sound warm.
The D-18 is also given scalloped X bracing. The X bracing refers to an X-shaped bracing underneath the top shell of the guitar, usually right underneath the sound hole. To make scalloped bracing, guitar makers usually remove some wood from the straight bracing, forming a very wide U-shape. Scalloped bracing usually helps to amplify the sounds from the middle ranges, which explains D-18’s sound.
As a result, the D-18 has a more warm and full-sounding tone, with a particular focus on the mid-range sounds. This makes D-18 a ‘balanced’ guitar without tilting to the bass or the treble sounds.
HD-28: The HD-28 is made with solid East Indian Rosewood for its back and side. Rosewood is denser than mahogany, meaning it would be harder for the air vibration to escape the guitar body through the wood. As a result, the sound quality changes and becomes different than the D-18.
The HD-28 is also given scalloped X bracing. This area made it different from its predecessor, the D-28. The D-28 has straight bracing with no scalloping. This made HD-28 different in sound compared to D-28. But the different wood types made the HD-28 sound different from the D-18.
As a result, the HD-28 has a richer and brighter tone. The dense Rosewood also helps the HD-28 to have a stronger treble and bass emphasis. As a result, you may hear more sound ranges in an HD-28, making it more appealing for fingerstyle players.
The HD-28’s stronger bass and boom also made it more ‘authoritative,’ producing a rich and booming sound. It is said that you could strum the guitar somewhere and turn heads or even stop conversations between people.
D-18 is cheaper than the HD-28, usually by several hundred dollars. This is due to the material differences and things such as the casing.
Wood types: HD-28 becomes more expensive than HD-18 because it uses Rosewood. Compared to Mahogany, Rosewood is harder to source and has become more and more protected by the day.
Martin uses a type of Rosewood from Southern India called the East Indian Rosewood. The term ‘East Indian’ is meant to differ between India and the West Indies/Caribbean, which may sometimes be called ‘West Indian.’
However, regulations for the use and importation of Rosewood were tightened in 2017, making it harder to import it into the US. The restrictions are set to make Rosewood more expensive in the future.
Inlays: HD-28 is more expensive because it uses a more intricate abalone inlay design than the one you see in the D-18. More intricate design means more work hours are spent creating the inlays, likely increasing the production cost.
Casing: HD-28 fetches a higher price as it comes with a more premium, molded-hardshell case. You can tell the difference if you compare this with the D-18’s ply-hardshell case. A molded case usually fits the guitar better and consumes more time, which means it may be more expensive.
Weight: The HD-28 is slightly heavier than the D-18. The HD-28 has a weight of 4.7 pounds (2.13KG), while the D-18 is weighed at 4.2 pounds (1.9KG). The weight difference may be small, but to some players, it gives the HD-28 a more sturdy, solid feel than the D-18, which makes it feel more premium and expensive.
Which Is The Best Guitar For You?
Suppose you are an intermediate player and are willing to invest more into your guitar. In that case, the D-18 is a good choice, as it is cheaper and is more ‘forgiving.’ Aspiring professionals or advanced players can get the HD-28, as it can make you sound truly professional. D-18 and HD-28 may not suit beginners well.
Overall, both D-18 and HD-28 are for players who have spent time honing their guitar playing skills and are looking for a new guitar to replace their beginner guitar. This is because intermediate or advanced-level players can appreciate the quality of these guitars and may see the point of shelling out the money for them.
Newer or beginner players may consider more affordable Martin guitars such as the LX1. Newer or beginner players may not be able to play the D-18 and the HD-28 to their full potential, which may mean they are underutilizing their purchase.
Instead of spending so much money on these great guitars immediately, they may want to spend the money on tutoring to improve their playing.
If you are a seasoned player deciding between the two, the D-18 may be better if you want a more ‘forgiving’ guitar at a lower price. D-18 focuses more on the mid-range, which means if you make mistakes on the low or high-ended sounds, it may not be too obvious. Plus, D-18 is cheaper by a few hundred dollars too.
The HD-28 is for true, committed guitarists. The HD-28 is also for aspiring professionals who wish to sound like idols. By owning an HD-28, you join legendary artists such as Bob Dylan, Johnny Cash, or James Hetfield and produce sounds just like when they play live.
The HD28 may also be very good for live shows since it has the ‘authoritative’ sound that helps you pull your audience’s attention. Its higher focus on low and higher-end sound also helps to make your finger plucking sound better.